The Holland Park Circle   
Artists and Victorian society, by Caroline Dakers (Yale University Press, 1999)


Art books are normally organized around artists and movements, an exhibition or a gallery. But Dakers takes a different approach, and looks at the houses they built and lived in, within a small area of West London (just north of the The Victoria and Albert Museum). Between the 1850s and 1890s, much of the land surrounding Holland House in this previously semi-rural part of London was sold off for building. A number of the plots were purchased by artists who had benefited from the buoyant market for pictures, and who built houses designed by the avant-garde architects of the day. Then as now, most significant English artists lived in London, and for a while Leighton's presidency of the RA made Holland Park its most prestigious artistic enclave. Some of these artists' houses can still be seen today, although only Leighton House and Linley Sambourne House are open to the public. Holland House itself was largely destroyed in World War II, and the remainder of its grounds are now a public park.
   Each chapter of this book is more-or-less a free-standing essay, but the author doesn't simply move from house to house, but takes a broadly chronological approach, while coming at her subject from different angles: for instance, there is a chapter about the artists' military and musical sidelines. One consequence of the essay style is that many characters walk on and walk off without too much ceremony: to get the most from this book you already need some familiarity the Victorian art world. There are plenty of footnotes, but mostly they comprise a scrupulous itemization of original sources: there is no list of 'further reading'.
   The artistic community of Holland Park was dominated by Leighton and Watts: the latter had been in with Lord Holland since the 1840s, and was a long-term house-guest of the Prinseps at Little Holland House in the 1850s. Of necessity, these two artists also dominate any account of the Holland Park Circle. However, both of them are now quite well served by modern biographies, and perhaps the most revealing chapters of this book are about minor figures, whose paintings may be familiar, but whose biographies are not: they include Fildes, Normand and his wife, Prinsep, Schmalz, James Shannon, and Stone. There is also of course quite lot about the architects and decorators, such as Burges, Shaw and Webb, and lots of photographs of the houses they built, and their interiors, mainly extracted from The Builder and Building News; these publications seem to have had some affinity with Hello! magazine in terms of the purple prose that was deployed to describe both and occupants.
   There are many out-of-the way titbits, such as enjoyably salacious details of the affair between Princess Louise (1848-1939) and the sculptor Edgar Boehm (1834-1890), and the latter's dramatic death. And a whole chapter is devoted to a usefully linear account of the Ionides family, who often appear in a fragmented and confusing way -- the men as patrons and the ladies as 'beauties' -- in other books. In addition, many of the illustrations are agreeably unusual: for instance, instead of using the ubiquitous photograph of Moore from Baldry's biography, the author has turned up a much less well-known sketch from the NPG.
   Unfortunately there are imperfections. For instance, the author appears not to have seen Normand's 'Bondage', which is described as a "tableau of bound women", which it is not (to the disappointment of many, no doubt). The index also has defects: for example, in compiling this little review one finds that Princess Louise is not listed under "Princess" or "Louise", as you might expect but under "HRH", an honorific that is however omitted in the case of her mother. On the subject of queens, one notes that "Queen Anne style" is followed by the unnecessary variants "Queen Anne" and "Queen Anne period". And "Bondage" is not indexed at all, although two other pictures by Normand are there. Final moan: there is no proper list of plates so that, for instance, you are given no idea how big the original of any painting might be.
   In summary, this book presents a facet of the Victorian art world as its habitués would have seen it: for, with their children looked after by nannies and no TV to distract them, Victorians were always dropping in on their neighbours. It is an absorbing, but not an easy read. And you would do well to have some complementary sources of information to hand.
      Locate a copy of this book at Alibris

Home to phryne.com  Compiled by David Lavender and John Woodwark  ©2000-2007